Smokin` Buckeye BBQ in Carey

It's ice cream was great! I ordered a chocolate and vanilla twist. It was really hot outside though. But it was a great day for ice cream.

Great food. Big T and Porky Tots ( loaded) Quick service

Great BBQ! And love the ice cream!

Best bbq available in the area. Nothing else is close in any of the surrounding towns.

They have good food & desserts too. A bit pricey, but very tasty. We will go back for more.

Such a great and friendly place to eat

Very friendly staff, great barbecue and don't forget the ice cream for dessert!

Yummy sandwiches, and friendly service,

Good ice cream ,fried food and not bad hamburgers and big T's.

Great tasting food, great service!

We were looking at to feed the family so we ordered the family pack to go for 8-10. It feed 6 adults and 2 kids with leftovers that we used at breakfast and lunch the next day. Excellent service and super friendly. Definitely doing it again.

Food was great and the people are very good.

What an unexpected surprise! The brisket, the the ribs and the wings were wonderful! But the onion rings were out of site fantastic!The service was friendly and efficient even under the strain of our family visit of nearly 40 hungry guests!

The BBQ here is amazing, tender, flavorful, and the quantities are generous. Family owned for years and it shows, they really care about your dining experience! And as if that wasn’t enough, their ice cream is fantastic! Try the Orange and Vanilla Twist Cone for a special treat. Ask for Kinsey at the drive thru, she’ll treat you right!

We are proud owners of this restaurant. Great bbq, sandwiches and for dessert, Tofts Soft Serve Ice Cream.

The service was very friendly. I got the beef tater tots and where perfect! Nice and crispy! I also got the sampler diner and was very good! Best pulled pork I've had! The ribs where good and sausage was very good! Beans where different than anywhere I've been but good. The Mac and cheese was blah, wouldn't recommend it. Fry's where perfectly seasoned with cajon

Have eaten there numerous times and have always been pleased with the food and the service. Very reasonable.

Good ribs

Food is good! Kids love the icecream and service is friendly

John and Diane are amazing people, and amazing cooks! They keep their restaurant clean and their food delicious.

The very best. ( My favorite)in Ohio. Super BBQ with friendly service. You can't go wrong here!!!! Enjoy😊

Only ordered ice cream but it is hands down the best I've had in a while

The service can vary, but the food is always good. I eat here quite often with my family. I recommend that you stick to the BBQ offerings. The brisket sandwich and beefy tots are my personal favorites. I love all of the sauces. The sweet hot and habenero are great for those who love heat. The prices are a little high. They also have terrific soft serve ice cream. There's limited seating.

I used to live in Carey, and I was walking distance from here. The food was amazing, and so was the ice cream. My only complaint is that its slower than "fast" food, but they actually have to cook it, rather than warm it up. Nice place.

Slow service is always on the menu ,so plan accordingly actually eat before you go then by the time you get your food you'll be hungry again..

Had the bbq burger. Amazing!!

Delicious as always! Got the pulled pork sandwich. YUM!

Social distancing, going well

A little difficult to find, but very well worth the effort. Fabulous quality eats! Great place to eat.

A gem of Carey! This place has some award winning barbecue! The smoked meats are perfectly paired with their different barbecue sauces. The meats are incredibly tender, full of flavor, and a pleasure to eat.The service is top notch and I can’t recommend this place enough!

Great food good people work there need one in tiffin

Delicious and great prices!

Ate here for the first time today and it is one of the best bbq restraunts I have been to. I would make the hour drive to eat here regularly. We met the owner while there. He sat down and talked to us and told us a little about himself. Very friendly man with a wonderful staff behind him! He is in his 70s and has been in the bbq business for 50 years! No wonder why it is so good!! He said he was done with it after this year. I really hope some one who knows what they are doing can carry on what he has started. It would be a shame to lose this place.

Had the lunch special, pulled smoked pork sandwich with slaw and a toasted bun. It was very good! Great value and great service!

great food! great visit with owners

Was very good just a little pricey for me $25 for 1 person

Great little barbeque joint! Good food at reasonable prices. Great barbeque sauces! Try the Sweet-Hot!

There is 1 vegetarian dish other than dessert here and they make it well (mac'n'cheese). My friends and I really enjoyed our meal and the waitress' good sense of humor. No one said a single bad thing about the food and we left with 5 milkshakes so.. go here.

The buffet was very good

Delicious, friendly, warm 🤩

They were training a employee and they got my order wrong, they changed the menu at the restaurant but not online

Amazing food an good customer service

Fantabulous food.

Was working in the area from out of town. Great little place we found here for lunch. Food was awesome. Would come back again for sure!

Excellent BBQ & wonderful tots - your choice of toppings.

I'm not a BBQ expert by any means but I found their pulled pork and BBQ sauces - especially habenero hot - to be fantastic. A lot of food for the money and even the fries seemed freshly made from the potatoes. The sweet tea was delicious, too. Shame I could only visit once during my trip around Ohio.

Food was really good but but didn't get a refill until I was done eating.

Food was great, service was friendly. Our first time there, we will definitely be back!

I used to be a carhop here YEARS ago!!! The owners have changed & added on to the building since then, but I still love coming here!! The food is always great & the service too!!

Great little barbeque joint. Tried the pulled pork and beef brisket sandwiches. Both were fantastic! Reasonable prices! Try the Sweet Hot barbecue sauce!